“Ip Man 4: The Finale” Ends the Decade with Underwhelming Reviews
When Ip Man <葉問> was first released in 2008, it renewed a sense of pride for Chinese martial arts and Cantonese identity. Indeed, the film series had witnessed through some of Hong Kong’s most politically turmoiled times: when Ip Man 3 was released in 2015, Hong Kong was in the midst of an umbrella movement. Ip Man’s message of justice and fighting spirit resonated with many Hong Kong youths and those hopeful for a bright future ahead.
Even now, as the series drop its last film Ip Man 4: The Finale <葉問4：完結篇>, Hong Kong is going through another social movement. In many ways, Ip Man does echo the Cantonese spirit, and while previous releases were met with cheers and excitement, Ip Man 4 has been drowned with boycotts and unsatisfactory reviews.
With the news that Ip Man star Donnie Yen (甄子丹) and the film’s production Raymond Wong (黃百鳴) are supporters of China, many Hong Kong moviegoers have decided to boycott the film. Netizens even started to drop spoilers of the film’s ending before the movie’s release, and for the first time ever since the series started, moviegoers are not at all upset with getting spoiled.
Unlike major blockbuster films like Avengers: Endgame and Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker in which moviegoers would actually make an effort to avoid spoilers, the Ip Man series follow a predictable trajectory of events that render spoilers as a non-factor. Every film in the series would follow a similar format—Ip Man would first come across ignorant foreigners who would doubt his abilities and Chinese identity. He would then be challenged by other Chinese martial artists who have prejudices against wing chun.
Ip Man 4 is no exception to the format.
In the first film, Ip Man duels northerner Jin Shanzhao (portrayed by Louis Fan 樊少皇) and karate expert Miura (portrayed by Hiroyuki Ikeuchi 池内博之). In the second film, the arrogant and racist British boxing champion “The Twister” (portrayed by Darren Shahlavi) picks a fight with Ip Man while he struggles to overcome the intimidation of Hung Ga master Hung Chun-nam (Sammo Hung 洪金寶). In the third film, Ip Man duels with the boxer Frank (portrayed by Mike Tyson) and comes across one of his most challenging opponents—wing chun master Cheung Tin-chi (portrayed by Max Zhang 張晉). In the latest film, Ip Man comes across a tai chi master portrayed by Wu Yue (吳樾), and has a row with an American general portrayed by Scott Edward Adkins.
So when Ip Man 4’s spoilers rolled in online, no one was surprised. Though one may argue that Ip Man is a kung fu film—and plot is only secondary—but fight choreography in Ip Man 4 has been criticized as repetitive and unoriginal. Danny Chan’s (陳國坤) portrayal of Bruce Lee (李小龍) in the film was also met with criticism. As Chan does not have a martial arts background, he emphasized his portrayal of Bruce Lee on his mannerisms and “sounds”. Unfortunately, viewers found Chan’s portrayal as too harsh, specifically during moments where Chan performed Bruce Lee’s iconic shouts.
Source: HK01.com
This article is written by Addy for JayneStars.com.
First of all, as of 12/29, there is a 7.6/10 from imdb, 3.5/4 from Roger Ebert, a 4.8/5 rating of 594 ratings from Google, and a 90% rating from Rotten Tomato, maybe this article was only quoting the HK media, but in the west, that’s hardly ‘underwhelming reviews’.
Also, the source of this article was taken from an HK media (the bias is strong with this one). Secondly, the boycott happening in China is practically coming from HK only, a mere city of 7 million, even if the entire city doesn’t watch it, that doesn’t play a dent in Ip Man’s earnings and exposure. Thirdly, this is a major international release (by Chinese standards) there are plenty of major theatres showing it here in Canada, and plenty of people have seen it.
As a matter of fact, I watched it yesterday, my gf and I thought it was pretty good, better than a lot of Hollywood junk these days.
Most underwhelming reviews are coming from Hong Kong, of course, so…
Everyone knows what is happening in hong kong now. Their reviews is irrelevant. Only idiots will mix politics with movie quality….
What i dislike about this movies is, its the ending of Donnie Yen’s Ip Man Saga…Sad, Very Sad I don’t get another from it anymore.
Danny Chan – everyone knows this guy do not have any martial arts background. He did what he could.